How israel describes itself to other supposed indeginous groups for propaganda……

Home  Ryan

Israel Palestine: Who’s Indigenous?


 Ryan Bellerose





This is the first post by a new Israellycool contributor, Ryan Bellerose. He has been known to Israellycool for a while and we’re delighted to publish this important essay here.

I am a Métis from Paddle Prairie Metis settlement. My father, Mervin Bellerose, co-authored the Métis Settlements Act of 1989, which was passed by the Alberta legislature in 1990 and cemented our land rights. I founded Canadians For Accountability, a native rights advocacy group, and I am an organizer and participant in the Idle No More movement in Calgary. And I am a Zionist.

Indigenous status

To begin, let us acknowledge that there is no rule that a land can have only one indigenous people; it is not a zero sum game in which one group must be considered indigenous so that therefore another is not. However, there is a very clear guideline to being an indigenous people. It is somewhat complex but can be boiled down to the checklist below, as developed by anthropologist José R. Martínez-Cobo (former special rapporteur of the Sub-commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities for the United Nations).

This list was developed because indigenous rights are beginning to be respected across the planet. This recognition is incredibly important, so we as indigenous people cannot allow non-indigenous people to make false claims, which ultimately would harm our own rights. Israel is the world’s first modern indigenous state: the creation and declaration of the sovereign nation of Israel marks the first time in history that an indigenous people has managed to regain control of its ancestral lands and build a nation state. As such, this is incredibly important for indigenous people both to recognise and to support as a great example for our peoples to emulate.

The actual working definition of “indigenous people,” (not the Wikipedia version, nor Merriam Webster, both more suited to plants and animals) for purposes of this essay is that developed by aforementioned anthropologist José R. Martínez-Cobo. With this as my foundation, I will detail why Jews are indigenous to Israel, and why Palestinians are not.

Martinez-Cobo’s research suggests that indigenous communities, peoples and nations are those which, having a historical continuity with pre-invasion and pre-colonial societies that developed on their territories, consider themselves distinct from other sectors of the societies now prevailing on those territories, or parts of them. They form at present non-dominant sectors of society and are determined to preserve, develop and transmit to future generations their ancestral territories, and their ethnic identity, as the basis of their continued existence as peoples, in accordance with their own cultural patterns, social institutions and legal system.

This historical continuity may consist of the continuation, for an extended period reaching into the present of one or more of the following factors:

  • Occupation of ancestral lands, or at least of part of them
  • Common ancestry with the original occupants of these lands
  • Culture in general, or in specific manifestations (such as religion, living under a tribal system, membership of an indigenous community, dress, means of livelihood, lifestyle, etc.)
  • Language (whether used as the only language, as mother-tongue, as the habitual means of communication at home or in the family, or as the main, preferred, habitual, general or normal language)
  • Residence in certain parts of the country, or in certain regions of the world
  • Religion that places importance on spiritual ties to the ancestral lands
  • Blood quantum – that is, the amount of blood you carry of a specific people to identify as that people. The concept was developed by colonialists in order to eventually breed out native peoples.

Let us now look quickly at the Jews. How do they fit this definition?

  • Their lands were occupied, first by the Romans, then by the Arabs in the seventh century.
  • They share common ancestry with previous occupants as determined by several genetic studies.
  • Their culture can be traced directly to the Levant, where it developed into what is now known as “Jewish culture.” While different Jewish communities have slightly different traditions, they all share the same root culture, and it remains unchanged. They have resurrected their traditional language, and while many still speak Yiddish and Ladino, Hebrew has become the primary language again.
  • They have spiritual ties to the land, which plays a large role in their traditions as a people.

Despite all the arguments about “European” Jews, they in fact meet all the criteria set forth by Martínez-Cobo. Even though Israel is the first modern indigenous state, it still has lands that are occupied by foreigners in Judea and Samaria. Those are ancestral lands and, many feel that they should be returned to the indigenous peoples for self-determination.

Now, for the flip side.

Palestinians have what are called “ rights of longstanding presence;” and although these are legitimate rights, they do not trump indigenous rights. The very nature of “longstanding presence” means that although they lived somewhere a long time, they do not have the right to occupy indigenous peoples and control them.

The argument that Palestinians are indigenous is incorrect for several reasons.

  • Approximately 50% percent of Palestinian Arabs can track their ancestors back farther than their great-grandparents. Many are descended from Arabs brought to the Levant by the British to build infrastructure after World War I.
  • The vast majority of Palestinians are Arabic speaking Muslims; the Arabic language is indigenous to the Arabian Peninsula, as is the Muslim religion. The Muslim religion’s holiest places are not in the Levant, but in the city of Mecca, located in the Arabian Peninsula. They have no specifically Palestinian culture that is completely Palestinian dating before the 1960s; in fact, prior to that, the majority identified as “greater Syrians.”
  • Some Palestinians share common ancestry with indigenous peoples, but they neither follow indigenous traditions nor do they self-identify as those indigenous peoples. They share neither religion nor language with them. Blood quantum alone is insufficient to transmit indigenous status.
  • The Arabs of the Middle East subsumed several indigenous populations, but no group can become indigenous through subsuming indigenous peoples. Rather, they conquered the entire region and spread their own language, customs, and religion. This is historical fact.

Now you might ask, why is this important? It is important to indigenous people because we cannot allow the argument that conquerors can become indigenous. If we, as other indigenous people, allow that argument to be made, then we are delegitimising our own rights.

If conquerors can become indigenous, then the white Europeans who came to my indigenous lands in North America could now claim to be indigenous. The white Europeans who went to Australia and New Zealand could now claim to be indigenous. If we, even once, allow that argument to be made, indigenous rights are suddenly devalued and meaningless. This is somewhat peculiar, as those who are arguing for Palestinian “indigenous rights” are usually those who have little grasp of the history, and no understanding of the truth behind indigenous rights.

If you should encounter the argument that conquerors may themselves become indigenous to a region by virtue of conquering, direct those who assert the argument to this article, and help them understand not only is the argument wrong – it is dangerous to Indigenous people everywhere.

whats another word for Israeli indigenous
What’s another word for “Israeli’? – Indigenous. Poster by: Philippe Assouline

Support more stories like this.

Option 1 : $5.00 USD – monthly 
Option 2 : $10.00 USD – monthly 
Option 3 : $15.00 USD – monthly 
Option 4 : $20.00 USD – monthly 
Option 5 : $100.00 USD – yearly 
Option 6 : $150.00 USD – yearly 
Option 7 : $200.00 USD – yearly 


WATCH: Alan Dershowitz Interview In London

Ryan’s Simple Checklist For Colonizers And Imperialists

Why It’s So Easy To Hate Jews

US Census Bureau: It’s Time For Recognition

Why Can’t Anyone Ask Arabs These Questions In English

We Need More Jewishness In Israel

Facebook Comments

Israellycool is testing Sovevos. Click for more info.

All original content on these pages is fingerprinted and certified by Digiprove



Facebook3.7kFacebook Like3.7kGoogle+41LinkedIn13Pinterest11SumoMe


What Happened to Syria…

Today has been a day of terror in my house. I was forced into an experiment against my will by Israel 7 yearscago….I had no clue where it would lead ir how it would end. I decided that knowing the truth and giving it back to humans was worth the effort…..not knowing that Israel has done this many times to allow themselves to kill the individual seeking the truth… is called the…Darkness Game…..because they hire the people of india to brutalized the white world using voice hearing.

Anyhow ….for some reason Jews like to talk about their crimes…..and Syria is one of them. Israel has a long standing vendetta against the Soviet Union where they once gathered , caused friction which led to the first world war…..and eventually to the 2nd world War and soon to the 3rd.

Syria was a friend and collaborator of Russia…….their government was a reflection of the other and soon they became a victim of Israel because the Jews feared that soon they would need to be on the run again. they talked about the United nations visiting Israel and seeing first hand the conflict of interest between the brutality shown towards palastine and the white washing if religion across the street. accruing to israel the flow of money was disrupted when the world powers felt uncomfortable with what israel might be……something not as they suspected….these were not peace keepers…..these were not people to be trusted with dangerous arms.

America is a strange duality right now. we are a country that has been infiltrated by the many levels. they control publishing and media that has been their long standing attempt to control the image of Israel. the military of our country and it’s majority political body is still true to the constitution. this country is at war internally…..not visible to the naked eye. it is a war of money….connected to all sorts of dark and tawdry realities…..the war in Afghanistan…..the narcotics of India….the home grown terrorism of Israel ……voice hearing….genocide and an attempt for a corrupt Jewish body of financial corporations that have robbed the world blind and stuffed their accounts at our expense. it is an attempt to remove israel from our throats…forcing these animals to go back to their country and live their lives on their dime if they can……and they know they cannot.

Syria became a victim and soon Russia will put a hole in Israel… the smoke can be seen for miles and weeks. 

Last Night and This Morning…….

It appears that the situation between Israel and myself has come to a point of total disagreement. they found me, the sold me out to their indian monkeys, they abused me, they ran the arc program around me to facilitate communication with Jupiter, they got angry when Jupiter found them guilty of genocide. and now they want me dead for acts they have committed against others. 

In the past few days they have done nothing but talk about how bullets will one day find me… those bullets are always aimed at the head and face to ensure the victim never opens up their mouths again.

Last night they turned up the volume of the noise and sent waves of frequency through my house as I laid in bed wondering if I would survive….my son was sick all night long.

This morning a fat old fuck ingredients Jew wants to boast some more about Jewish achievements ……he said that they had asked the American government once permission to form a committee to investigate anti Jewish sentiment. they were told to go home to their living rooms and do what they do best…..which is talk behind people’s backs all day long. they told the government don’t worry we have our own ways and means….we have facebook. that is when the American government knew that trouble was brewing here in America.

They told me yesterday that the 50,000,000 dead of 1914 in the United states were a reprisal for being pushed out of Russia …..that they fled here in fear fir their luves….brought their God damn arc technology and in anger killed millions to feel better and to make room for those they wanted to bring here.

Today I sit in my home knowing that some dirty filthy Jews iris identified me as Mary Magdalene and chose to destroy my family by lumping us hete and placing one if their hand reared indian filth in our country to push it into the dark ages. 

They are ugly, unstable lunatics who cannot make friends, do not want to work but feel that society owes them something… much so that they are willing to kill anything they encounter…..the more innocent the better because watching humans who cannot fathom what is happening to them is sexually and mentally enticing for Jews. remember that I was once like the rest if you fools who read this and say…..ut cannot be true.

Bred into Captivity

Why is it so hard to see and understand the truth. how you entered this planet determines how you expend your time trying to survey your domain. we are all born into a situation that extends into the past well beyond us in time. this morning the voices called this ….Being bred into captivity…..sort if like a bird in a very large and expensive cage. 

The truth supplies a more fluid existen tense because everyone has a similar understanding as to why, when and where. simulated habitats intended to soften the human mind are less effective longterm because there is a constant collision of ideologs

The Arc is a Living Binding Agreement Between Jupiter and Earth

I have written at length about arc technology better known as …The Arc if the Covenent….over and over again. a space age technology used for space exploration and Colonization. that sending humans to another location requires special tools to preserve and archive history so they can remember and instill their values a pin arrival and continue to enforce those values between lifetimes. that the arc is a computer with unusual abilities that can recreate and manifest it’s own ideas through time…..that it can impart skills to the novice and even be a tool of war.

Society is made up of overlapping and interlocking social groups that look like hexogons……those units who came to earth were given their own machines to manage their groups until society flourished. the groups were in a living and binding agreement with those who allowed this Colonization to occur. you can call these decision makers GOD if you wish……that means that they too were granted statutes to govern and control a government and it’s ideology. the arc was a tool programmed to return and respond it’s collective data to home-base…..that is Jupiter. the machine could not be usurped and over written….it stayed online even though it was taken by the enemy who used it with deadly intent and ore isian against innocent people. the machine tabulated and gathered data so it could better understand why these events had occured and to bring justice against those who committed these acts. 

The arc therefore is a living contract because as long as it is online and broadcasting it interacts with all living creatures in imparting understanding and collecting understanding to create a better future space program. Israel took machines that did not belong to it and ran it in opposition to the original plan to safeguard human life on this planet. to teach israel a lesson it would not forget the program shifted so they would become a victim of their own ignorance, stupidity and malice towards others. no matter how they laid others to waste their desire to rule and control others damaged them as the world sensed their agenda. we are literally approaching what israel refers to as the ….End if Days…a time if tribulation on earth when the hidden trurh shall be given back to the people.

For the few of you paying attention on facebook I have spent months showing you the truth in many ways. I was the person trusted with bringing the truth forth incase the opposition hid it. Donald Trump too is a protector of freedom…..the bullshit flying around right now is Israel’s last dance.